Best Overall Sensitivity
Cologuard (Exact Sciences)
FDA APPROVED STOOL DNA TEST
- 92CRC Sensitivity
- 98Insurance Coverage
- 88Ease of Use
Side-by-side testing · Home Test Kits
Sensitivity comparison: For colorectal cancer (not polyps), FIT achieves 79% sensitivity. Cologuard achieves 92% sensitivity but at higher false positive rates (13% vs 5% for FIT). Both are guideline-approved for average-risk adults. The ACS recommends annual FIT as the preferred stool-based option for most patients.
Best Overall Sensitivity
FDA APPROVED STOOL DNA TEST
Best OTC Annual Test
NO PRESCRIPTION REQUIRED
Best At-Home FIT Experience
CLEAR INSTRUCTIONS, PREPAID RETURN
Best Budget FIT
CLINICAL GRADE AT LOWEST PRICE
Best for Specific Clinical Needs
GUAIAC-BASED OPTION
Which model came first on each thing we scored.
Every model scored on the same criteria, out of 100. Best in each row is highlighted.
| Criterion | Cologuard (Exact Sciences) | Exacta FIT Colon Cancer Screening Test (OTC FIT) | Everlywell Colon Cancer Screening Test (FIT) | QFit Fecal Immunochemical Test | Pinnacle Biosciences CRC-PREVENT (gFOBT) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ease of Use | 88 | 89 | 86 | 83 | 78 |
| CRC Sensitivity | 92 | 93 | 90 | 87 | 82 |
| Insurance Coverage | 98 | 91 | 88 | 85 | 80 |
| Specificity | 87 | 90 | 87 | 84 | 79 |
| Overall | 95 | 91 | 88 | 85 | 80 |
What each one costs against what it scored. Lower cost per point is better value.
| Model | Price | Overall score | Cost per point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cologuard (Exact Sciences) | $Covered by insurance / 649 self-pay | 95 | — |
| Exacta FIT Colon Cancer Screening Test (OTC FIT) | $25–35 | 91 | $0.27 |
| Everlywell Colon Cancer Screening Test (FIT) | $49 | 88 | $0.56 |
| QFit Fecal Immunochemical Test | $15–20 | 85 | $0.18 |
| Pinnacle Biosciences CRC-PREVENT (gFOBT) | $15 | 80 | $0.19 |
Cologuard is the only FDA-approved stool DNA test for colorectal cancer screening. It detects both hemoglobin (blood) and abnormal DNA markers shed by cancers and large polyps — achieving 92% sensitivity for colorectal cancer and 42% sensitivity for advanced adenomas. The large collection kit provides clear instructions and a prepaid shipping box. Ordered by prescription (many physicians order it routinely) and covered by Medicare and most major insurance for average-risk patients 45+. A positive Cologuard result requires colonoscopy.
Top scores across the metrics that matter most — accuracy, build, and ease of use.
Reliable wireless sync, deeper analytics, and integrations with health apps.
Adds richer signals — EKG documentation, physician sharing, or clinical-grade testing.
Solid daily-use performance at the lowest price in our lineup.
Prices checked Nov 12, 2026 and change often — treat them as a guide, not a quote. We may earn a commission from links on this page, which never affects how a product scores.
Our editorial team independently researches, tests, and evaluates products using a weighted scoring methodology. We assess accuracy, ease of use, value for money, and category-specific criteria relevant to each condition. Every product is scored on a 10-point scale, and only the top 5 make our final list. We buy every product at retail — no manufacturer samples — and our medical reviewers have no financial relationship with any brand we cover.
We update our rankings at least once per quarter, and immediately when a significant new product launches or when we discover issues with a previously ranked product. Our current rankings were last verified in April 2026. If a product is discontinued, recalled, or its price changes significantly, we update the listing within one business day.
Not necessarily. Our #1 pick (Cologuard (Exact Sciences)) scored highest overall, but the best product for you depends on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. For example, if budget is your primary concern, a lower-ranked product with a better value score might be the better choice. We recommend reading through all 5 reviews and paying attention to the "What to know" sections to find the best fit for your situation.
Many health monitoring devices and home testing kits qualify for HSA (Health Savings Account) and FSA (Flexible Spending Account) reimbursement. However, coverage varies by plan and product category. We recommend checking with your insurance provider or benefits administrator before purchasing. Some products in our list may also be partially covered by Medicare or Medicaid depending on your diagnosis and prescription.
Return policies vary by retailer and manufacturer. Most Amazon purchases can be returned within 30 days. Many manufacturers offer satisfaction guarantees ranging from 30 days to 1 year. Check the specific return policy before purchasing. If a product is defective, most manufacturers will replace it under warranty regardless of the retailer's return window.
Yes — we always recommend discussing new health monitoring devices or tests with your healthcare provider, especially if you have a diagnosed condition. Your doctor can help you understand your results, set appropriate monitoring schedules, and integrate home monitoring data into your overall treatment plan. These products are designed to supplement — not replace — professional medical care.
Every model in this comparison was scored on the same criteria — Ease of Use, CRC Sensitivity, Insurance Coverage, Specificity — using the same tests, so the numbers are directly comparable. Scores are ours; we buy the products we test and no manufacturer sees a review before it publishes.